Everything is fresh and well prepared. The place was packed, but not super noisy. Add a photo . Peter's of Millburn's cuisine combines old world recipes with modern flair that utilizes the finest ingredients to charm even the most discerning of palette. This site uses cookies to improve your experience, to enhance site security and to show you personalised advertising. Good dependable basic Italian food, with very good fish specials. Its a little pricey at $16 for lunch, but the portion was a nice size.More, We had heard so many good things about this restaurant and we were able to get reservations before a show at the Papermill. We stopped there for dinner before seeing the show at the Papermill Playhouse. We ordered clams oreganata and the mussels with white sauce to share. Highly recommended!! Both were outstanding.More, This is the version of our website addressed to speakers of English in United Kingdom. Hotels near (EWR) Newark Liberty Intl Airport, Hotels near (JFK) John F. Kennedy Intl Airport, Italian Restaurants for Families in Millburn, Italian Restaurants for Special Occasions in Millburn. Peter is always a delight and his food has that farm to table quality! Peter's of Millburn. The portions are generous, the food is tasty and the prices are reasonable. Good, dependable, consistent place to go for a quality meal at very reasonable prices. Go early if a table for 2 is required as there are only reservations for 4 or more. The shrimp was delicious and the sauce had just enough heat. Get quick answers from Peter's of Millburn staff and past visitors. Overall disappointed and preferred Basillico as our favorite Italian restaurant in Millburn. I ordered the hotsy totsy shrimp as an entree over home made pasta, which was like a long fusilli. Good dependable basic Italian food, with very good fish specials. Peter and his head chef hand select daily specials based on the season's best produce available and You can choose breaded or grilled. Food is excellent.. Bring good friends and a great bottle of wine." Very tasty. Love the seafood dishes, but have trouble resisting the chicken parm! Love the seafood dishes, but have trouble resisting the chicken parm! I had the ravioli and was not disappointed. See all restaurants in Millburn. The restaurant is small and the owners (Peter and his father Peter) are great people!! It's a more intimate dining experience, and while theMore. Hotels near (EWR) Newark Liberty Intl Airport, Hotels near (JFK) John F. Kennedy Intl Airport, Italian Restaurants for Families in Millburn, Italian Restaurants for Special Occasions in Millburn. All photos (2) All photos (2) Enhance this page - Upload photos! Another person ordered mixed seafood over linguini. Peter's of Millburn is an Italian restaurant in Millburn, NJ. The clams were delicious. Does this restaurant offer table service? Delicious cuisine in friendly atmosphere. I enjoyed meeting the owners and the delicious food. The atmosphere is nice casual and is always welcoming! I ordered the chicken sandwich with broccoli rabe. My husband and I had a very nice experience at this restaurant. We sat outside at one of maybe four tables they haveset up on the sidewalk and it was fine though there was a constant stream of people strolling by on their way to other places. This is a smaller restaurant and one were the owner is present and visible. I had the breaded artichoke salad and my husband had the Italian peppers with sliced thin potatoes. This is a smaller restaurant and one were the owner is present and visible. Enhance this page - Upload photos! It comes with a side salad. I had the Swordfish and it was perfectly cooked! The menu is not huge, but offers enough variety. You can choose breaded or grilled. I ordered the hotsy totsy shrimp as an entree over home made pasta, which was like a long fusilli. The menu is not huge, but offers enough variety. Reservations for 4 or more! My husband ordered the Veal Marsala and said it was overcooked and could not taste the Marsala wine. Save. The shrimp was delicious and the sauce had just enough heat. Delicious cuisine in friendly atmosphere. Good, dependable, consistent place to go for a quality meal at very reasonable prices. This small neighborhood restaurant is a nice change from some of the larger Italian restaurants in Millburn, and has a lot of "regulars" who come frequently.More. To learn more about catering, click the button below. Id return for the tasty food and pleasant atmosphere. If you are a resident of another country or region, please select the appropriate version of Tripadvisor for your country or region in the drop-down menu.