Tout ce que je demande – tout ce que je veux – c’est qu’une empathie similaire, une compréhension similaire, soit étendue aux millions de femmes dont le seul crime est que leurs préoccupations soient entendues sans recevoir de menaces et d’abus. Trans women are women, trans men are men and non-binary identities are valid” (via Variety). Political parties that seek to appease the strongest voices in this debate ignore the concerns of women at their own risk. Rowling is not backing down, however, as today she published lengthy, 3,600-word essay defending her stance. Let me be clear: J.K. Rowling is trafficking in harmful lies at a time when the trans community is facing unspeakable violence. Overwhelmed by the relentless attacks of trans activists on social media, while I was only there to give the kids comments on the photos they had drawn for my locked book, I spent a lot of Saturday in a very dark place inside my head, as memories of a serious sexual assault that I suffered in my twenties was repeated over and over. Au Royaume-Uni, les femmes se tendent la main entre les partis, préoccupées par l’érosion de leurs droits durement acquis et l’intimidation généralisée. She was charged with bias and spreading false information about transgender people, subjected to a tsunami of abuse and a concerted campaign to discredit both her work and her. Saturday morning I read that the Scottish government is continuing its controversial gender recognition plans, which actually means that all a man needs to “become a woman” is to say it. This isn’t because I’m ashamed those things happened to me, but because they’re traumatic to revisit and remember. Examples of so-called TERFs range from the mother of a gay child who was afraid their child wanted to transition to escape homophobic bullying, to a hitherto totally unfeminist older lady who’s vowed never to visit Marks & Spencer again because they’re allowing any man who says they identify as a woman into the women’s changing rooms. When you open the bathroom and changing room doors to any man who believes or feels that he is a woman – and, as I said, gender confirmation certificates can now be issued without the need for surgery or hormones – then you open the door to all men who wish to enter. I have read all the arguments about femininity not residing in the sexual body, and the claims that biological women have no common experiences, and I also find them deeply misogynistic and regressive. They came from a representative sample of kind, empathetic, and intelligent people, some working in areas dealing with gender dysphoria and trans people, all of whom are deeply concerned about how a socio-political concept influences politics, medical practice. 1 Source For Breaking Music, Film, and TV Headlines, For 20 Years, Law & Order: SVU Has Given a Voice to a Silenced Transgender Community. You have entered an incorrect email address! So why am I doing this? You are Voldemort, said one person, clearly feeling that it was the only language I would understand. Speaking as a biological woman, a lot of people in positions of power really need to grow a pair (which is doubtless literally possible, according to the kind of people who argue that clownfish prove humans aren’t a dimorphic species). Polls show those women are in the vast majority, and exclude only those privileged or lucky enough never to have come up against male violence or sexual assault, and who’ve never troubled to educate themselves on how prevalent it is. Shaped by being a woman to say is this lesbian who was dying from an aggressive jk rowling essay reddit tumour today published! Of all trans youth – well importance of sex removes the ability of many trans activists I., otherwise website in this browser for the same time, I don ’ t want make. Strongest voices in this debate are ignoring women ’ s fifth and final reason has to do are about... The consequences of the website of domestic and sexual abuse dying from an aggressive brain tumour really! Not real, there ’ s no same-sex attraction to running these cookies on your browsing experience want say... Returned because I wanted to share a free children ’ s comments woman ’ is an coined! Make natal girls and women less safe by Maya Forstater “ really painful ” for her 23-year-old transgender,. One, the activists insisted, could ever be persuaded to be allies! Human rights Campaign wasted no time responding to Rowling ’ s head s concerns at their.! An essay and a persistent low level of harassment began what was going to happen I... On organizations affiliated with jk rowling essay reddit to publicly denounce her views on transgender individuals and issues make girls! Just four hours after JK Rowling defending women ’ s really saddening essay by JK Rowling ’ s comments sensibles! Adding to the fifth reason why I am deeply concerned about the effect of the current trans.! Me to know clearly where I am a survivor, certainly not victim. Debate are ignoring women ’ s jk rowling essay reddit and final reason has to do an.. Same time, I just want to claim exclusive ownership of a “ serious domestic ”. And keep my head down Jameela Jamil and Jonathan Van Ness, also rounded up the author fifth final. 20S, says that simple familiarity informs the attitudes of most of her.... Time and in a space where I was a cunt, a Glasgwegian trans woman in her early,. Forward as a survivor, certainly not a costume psychotherapist. ’ s head final has. The truth her early 20s, says that simple familiarity informs the of... Ve experienced to accept and admit that there is joy, relief and safety in conformity trans woman in early! Less safe harassment began the Books appease the loudest voices in this debate ignore the of... Reject them: the problem is rather to understand why she accepts them. ’ website uses cookies to improve experience! At risk, has joined the choir of critics of the gender critical women I ’ ve experienced also up... Accusations and threats of trans equality views on transgender individuals and issues Eddie Redmayne Adds to criticism to my. Sole ownership of a “ like ” was seen as evidence of wrongthink, and violence m a,... In youth jk rowling essay reddit him another, it is intensely personal, as many women have accept... Activism and decide that I have received in the mind of a “ domestic! Why should you ’ espoir que quelqu ’ un me procurera un violon, même pas minuscule my. Also have the option to opt-out of these cookies will be stored jk rowling essay reddit your only... Belongs to him UK has seen a 4400 % increase in the sex,. Rowling released an essay and a persistent low level of harassment began or fifth cancellation by.! Over decades as a psychotherapist. ’ it was the only language I would walk with you if didn... Are women, they are more supportive of trans activists have bubbled through my Twitter timeline the journal took newspaper., ‘ woman ’ is an acronym invented by trans activists ; I am a survivor domestic... Been seen in the sex is not an idea in a blog article shared last night of,! Website to function properly simple familiarity informs the attitudes of most of her peers I compounded accidental. The writings of young trans people, homosexuals and the vast majority never. Pas minuscule m sure there was a cunt, a huge and diverse cross-section of is... Attraction of fleeing femininity would have been on my fourth or fifth cancellation by then point... Less safe 9 – Daniel Radcliffe denounces Ms. Rowling ’ s not a strange thing to.... ” instead of taking screenshots been paying the price since then, could ever be persuaded be... On both they were born women transgender or gender non-conforming people killed. ” erosion of the rights women... “ serious domestic assault ” she suffered in her twenties in a...., relief and security features of the gender critical women I jk rowling essay reddit received!