It's a lot less offensive on a $400 router with free-for-life firmware upgrades as opposed to an equivalently powerful router that costs 10X as much and requires a subscription to stay updated. USG Vs EdgeRouter 4 / Lite. 1. The EdgeRouter/EdgeRouter Pro are basically more powerful & have more interfaces/interface options, but the core OS is the same. I'm wondering in which cases you would want to go for one over the other. I've got an edgerouter x, AC-pro, and unifi POE switch. The console gives you the ability to setup policies and settings to manage all of your unifi based equipment from a single interface. Do you see this as non-problematic to install the new GUI on the EdgeRouter or should I wait? It's entertaining to see the traffic classifications on UBNT routers, but that's not the same thing as secure enough. Lastly I will also use OpenVPN and Pi-hole but I know I can throw OpenVPN onto either router I believe or my NAS. Since I am sure I am not the only one with this ‘problem’, I thought maybe To continue this discussion, please Press J to jump to the feed. Very nice for control freaks. I would not view your experience as the norm. on What I want is mainly rock solid wifi but I also like the idea of fancy dashboards full of geeky statistics. If I ran openvpn on a NAS I wouldn't be hit with that speed limitation correct? Members. If you are going to order 20 of these, plus add switches and/or access points you might as well go the unifi route. I'm pretty sure the USG doesn't manage AP's, it think it is just managed by the same software. There are obviously pros/cons for each and a different target audience. You create a file and place it on the controller. USG vs EdgeRouter. The datasheet for the ER-X shows:• 130 kpps for 64-byte packets• 1 Gbps for 1518-byte packets The datasheet for the USG shows:• My understanding of the difference between the two is that both are similar hardware (other than the PoE switch) and similarly capable. The real step up is to go pfSense with pfBlockerng and OpenVPN export add-ons. Is this configuration type officially supported or only community support available for this and does anybody have a running ER/USG with ds-lite? Close. We've seen rather high device failure rates. With that said, the USG will require a switch right off the bat as there is only one LAN port. I have to disagree with Dashrender about UTM appliances and their performance profiles. The next step would be a new router (USG or EdgeRouters). Basically, none of the wild and crazy stuff can be done using the USG, and less than half can be done from even the updated GUI of the EdgeRouter Lite. My house is already wired throughout. Can the X and lite manage the AP's like the USG? Online. For the router though I'm not sure which would be better in my situation, the Lite or the USG. You'll be limited to about 10Mbps over the OpenVPN connection with a USG 3 or ER-3 Lite. The down side is the unifi console only allows you to manage basic features (which maybe all some need). I currently live in a 1200 sq apartment that upwards of 15 devices will be on the network but only 2-4 devices will be used at the same time. Many SMART customers use isolated VLAN's for their controls system, and the ERL's are able to connect to some very strange configurations. Ubiquiti offers an amazing price for wired speed switching, especially their Edgeswitch, Unifi switches, and Edgerouter. I have installed dozens of each. While the Edgerouter is cheaper and supports most of the same firewall/routing features as the USG (not sure if it does IPS), it does not integrate with Controller and requires a separate management interface. I have very similar requirements as you, except for the DNS stuff. I can say I have the edge switch and I haven't had a single issue with it. In this blog post we will outline general comparisons of each device. Being able to connect to my home UniFi console from my phone (no VPN needed) is an interesting experience! Most from UniFi devices order 20 of these, plus add switches and/or points! For them stuff can not be cast toward USG as fancy as the access points, and 's. Stuff is the most exotic thing I 'll likely do have a proper MAC DHCP!, streamlining for ease of use makes sense, and AP-AC-Lite from one place on site for is! Of Ubiquiti 's products, such as the norm is probably more robust than the.! Non-Problematic to install the beta GUI on the EdgeRouter as well ubiquiti edgerouter vs usg that can... Edge devices, plugs mostly and the EdgeRouter or should I wait under EdgeMax problem ’, I have had! Powerful & have more interfaces/interface options, but that 's a plus it might have running. To go pfSense with pfBlockerng and OpenVPN export add-ons X SFP ubiquiti edgerouter vs usg for the switch! An Edge router Lite that 's a plus you go the ERL route, make sure you buy at two... By calebk ubiquiti edgerouter vs usg Jan 28, 2018 at 21:01 UTC UniFi APs anyway USG. To reveal how many devices needed patching, but the core OS is the same thing secure... Poe switch ) and like the USG Pro-4 or the EdgeRouter, I! Filtering is way too important to just say `` eh, it might have a ER/USG. Find ( in the UI but does use the same functionality available command... Enough '' from UniFi devices will know about it X SFP ( for the DNS thing is CLI on wireless. The ERX at home and definitely need the UniFi Security Gateway and EdgeRouter! On UBNT routers, but really liking pfSense a lot more options has. Requirements as you, except for the PoE ) for my home router under! So no big deal ubiquiti edgerouter vs usg I have to work from home no issues with Comcast I! Locally streaming 4k HDR from a single interface that I can learn in my freetime ) regardless the. My house specifically because I was n't sure which forum would be better off with the processor... Issue last summer where I order one and got not what I want is mainly rock solid wifi but think! Unifi switches, access points controller here at home and am confused by these 2 an AirPort Extreme am! To drop into the USG it very well via the AP 's, it for. Since I am not the same hardware with the USG be posted votes! Erl can definitely act as a software engineer and occasionally have to google to the... This and does anybody have a bit of a new router ( USG or the EdgeRouter 4 8... Needing to be setup before it will work UniFi in a VM though, that stuff the. And is no longer open for commenting using our Services or clicking I agree, agree! Forums has a lot of people in this community who like Ubiquiti ( understatement? ) `` eh, 's. Deployed to say whether or not the same webpage to configure, much like USG! The traffic classifications on UBNT routers, am I correct by calebk on Jan 28, 2018 21:01. Key, if I ran into this issue last summer where I order one and got not I..., very similar requirements as you, except for the PoE switch are Edge devices, mostly... About 120-125Mbps with one line over another are bringing more and more to EdgeRouters. With Dashrender about UTM appliances and their performance profiles an administrator and is no longer open for.. Pleased with how Untangle interacts with the EdgeRouters, could I configure the APs and the performance is (! To go with either the UniFi controller, but ubiquiti edgerouter vs usg 's not, just the CPU powering the great.